7

The below is a personal proposal, this is nothing official. So I do not hold any authority over what I describe below and am merely asking you to follow along - obviously nobody has to. Edits are welcome except for voting scheme, as changing that later on is unfair. So if you don't like that, follow point 1. below: Downvote the question.

Background

Some recent questions about "how/why something is called ..." again triggered usage of any or several of the (alphabetically ordered) tags , and (if I missed another candidate, please add). In Naming vs nomenclature this has been partially discussed, but no clear stance on what to do has been taken. As we will not reach enough questions to duplicate them by the usual ways, I hope to get a clear result and then a manual intervention by a moderator. Obviously there is no guarantee this will happen, but it can happen.
Why would one even want synonyms (if they actually are synonyms): It more consistently groups questions and only one tag description has to be maintained.

Voting scheme

Therefore I propose to make a clear poll to decide whether these tags should be made synonyms and which should be master. Intended rules:

  1. If you don't like my rules, if you don't think these are synonyms or if you in general don't thing we should manually meddle with tag synonyms:
    Downvote the question.
  2. If you do think at least a subset of these should be duplicated:
    Upvote the question and use votes on answers to support your favorite.
  3. If there is no answer that describes the synonym setup you would like to choose:
    Create an appropriate answer and make it a community wiki (and optionally state your case).

Answer scheme

An answer should begin with absolutely unambiguous statement of which tags should be synonyms and which tag should be the main tag. A fictional example between eclair, pie and tart:

Synonyms: pie, tart  
Main tag: pie  
Separate: eclair  

After that you could add whatever reasoning you want for your choice (or expand on it, if something is already there).
If you have a much better idea for main tag than the existing tags, you obviously can introduce it, but this will split votes over even more proposals, making a consensus harder. So please consider whether it is actually worth it.

Please, do not use this Q&A for discussion in answers. If you consider my schema as unusable, close-vote, down-vote, comment on and/or edit it, but please don't mess the poll up in case it turns out to be usable.

Termination

This poll should certainly run for some time. Unless they object, I would leave specifying a termination criteria (date, vote count, vote differential, ...) to the moderators. After all it is them who have to do the manual intervention on the tags, so they have the last word anyway.

  • 2
    Pie's not a good example, because a pie can be mash potato covered meat... or meat in pastry, as well as a dessert / pudding :) – Aravona Jan 27 '17 at 10:09
  • @Aravona :D I so knew a comment like this would come - please go ahead and change the example. Synonyms (and intricacies why something is not a synonym) are in my opinion something of the hardest to get right in a foreign language. – imsodin Jan 27 '17 at 10:26
10

Synonyms:

Main tag:

Ok I'll bite!

Why?

I think is the more generic technical word. I don't use at all and is a bit informal. is the more formal, technical word.

  • 2
    I'd agree terminology! Also with terminology I'd find 'naming-convention' springs to mind as a term I use more than naming, you know just to throw another spanner in the works. – Aravona Jan 27 '17 at 16:33
  • I think your right @Erik I actually totally changed my answer and left this in based on the original. I've removed it now, because your correct – user2766 Feb 6 '17 at 10:39
2

Update:

I manually merged and into .

The tag seemed to be used the most often and synonyms take forever to get created, so I thought it was easiest this way.

I actually happened quite a while ago, I just saw this meta post again and though I would leave an update.

  • 1
    Fine. I know what nomenclature is, of course, but I doubt I have ever used the word. Naming is clearly a subset of terminology. – ab2 Mar 20 '18 at 0:41

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .